Click the count in the Detections column to go to the Logs The diversity in terms of physical characteristics will only increase. Our Stamus Security Platform combines the best of intrusion detection (IDS), network security monitoring (NSM), and network detection and response (NDR) systems into a single solution that exposes serious and imminent threats to critical assets and empowers rapid response. This website uses cookies. Worry-Free Business Security Services, Worry-Free Business Security Services Find specific objects in the list. Thats a very good example we have here: hello gurus website uses server-side profiling to optimize its weight. Overly long and detailed User-Agent But on the real world, a new platform or browser is not coming out from nowhere and be > 10% of the market share in a couple days. Click the Object link to view details and make changes. The screenshots shown are heavily redacted due to the sensitivity of the investigation and of the nature of the supply chain breach that was involved. A user account was modified to password never expires; A user added a Windows firewall rule; A user authenticated with weak NTLM to multiple hosts; A user changed the Windows system time; A user cleared their browser's history; A user connected a USB storage device for the first time; A user connected a new USB storage device to a host I have several questions about using Worry-Free Services to protect me from ransomware. RFC 1945 (HTTP 1.0) says the following: The User-Agent request-header field contains information about the user agent originating the request. Some normal applications and scripts may contain no user agent. Please feel free to star the repository to keep in Splunk Observability has two new enhancements to make it quicker and easier to troubleshoot slow or frequently 2005-2022 Splunk Inc. All rights reserved. A better suggestion would be to perform some anomaly detection or machine learning on user agent strings that exist within your environment and even that might be a fool's errand. Responsive design is hard to achieve if your web site or web application is not simple one page demo. I did a lookup csv file that included suspicious user-agents characters like below. Im not supporting (aka testing) Bada or WebOS. Sorry if I am resurrecting and old thread but I find this subject very important and I am still not happy with my knowledge on this subject. Browse to upload a suspicious object Its a topic I have not addressed in this article. My favorite site for this is user-agent-string.info. do content adaption on the fly, aka the responsibility of the client and the device with regards to the browsing experience. A few of them below. tokens of other implementations in order to declare compatibility I did a lookup csv file that included suspicious user-agents characters like below. Additional results searching for strings used in HTTP user agents.Initially, the symbols in the HTTP user agents seemed arbitrary and did not make any sense to us in isolation -- even after a rough translation. By clicking Accept, you consent to the use of cookies. Re: How to search suspicious user-agent in web req Five Subtly Different Ways of Adding Manual Instrumentation in Java, New Splunk APM Enhancements Help Troubleshoot Your MySQL and NoSQL Databases Faster. This can be due to persistence, command-and-control, or exfiltration activity. :). By using this capability, we were easily able to identify all the offending systems. Security Agent, Comparing Features of Worry-Free Editions, Windows Security Agent Minimum Requirements, Android Security Agent Minimum Requirements, Network Traffic During Pattern File Updates, Security Agent Installation Send Installer Link, Installing the Agent on a Windows Computer, after Receiving the Email, Installing the Agent on a Mac, after Receiving the Email, Installing the Profile on an iOS Device, after Receiving the Email, Installing the Agent on an Android Device, after Receiving the Email, Security Agent Installation Download Installer, Download Installer Same Group and Account Installation, Download Installer Different Group and Account Installation, Security Agent Installation Install on This Endpoint, Chrome Extension Mass Deployment for Chromebooks, Removing the Security Agent from the Web Console, Removing the Security Agent from Android Devices, Removing the Security Profile from iOS Devices, Migrating from Other Antivirus Applications, Comparison of Security Agent and Trend Micro Anti-Spyware Settings, Preventing Upgrade for Selected Security Agents, Disabling Upgrades on Mac Security Agents, Viewing Security Agent Icons in the Windows System Tray, Restoring Endpoints from Manual to Active Directory Domain Groups, Endpoint Commands and Information: Windows, Endpoint Commands and Information: Android, Comparison between Classic and Advanced Modes, Configuring Predictive Machine Learning Settings, Wildcard Support for the Device Control Allowed Programs List, Configuring Data Loss Prevention Exceptions, Rule 1: Maximum Size of a Decompressed File, Blocking Access to Data Recorders (CD/DVD), Excluding Files, Folders, and File Extensions from Scans, Supported System Variables for File and Folder Exceptions, Configuring the Spyware/Grayware Approved List, Configuring the Behavior Monitoring Exception List, Behavior Monitoring Exception List Wildcard Support, Configuring the Approved/Blocked URL Lists, Configuring Privileges and Other Settings, Excluding Files and File Extensions from Scans, Configuring the Global Approved IP Address List for Web Reputation and URL Filtering, Configuring the Global Allowed Process List, Configuring the Global Windows Trusted Program List, Configuring the Global Mac Trusted Program List, Configuring the Global Predictive Machine Learning Exception List, Configuring the Global Allowed USB Device List, Adding Exceptions to the Allowed USB Device List, Importing Device Information to the Allowed USB Device List, Configuring the Global Approved IP Address List for Vulnerability Protection, Adding Objects to the User-Defined Suspicious Object List, Virtual Analyzer Suspicious Object Exception List, Supported System Variables for Application Control Rules, Network Bandwidth Consumption Resulted from Application Reputation List Updates, Mobile Device Management Commands - Incomplete, Mobile Device Management Commands - Pending, Smart Protection Services - Agents Disconnected, Clicking the Enable Ransomware Protection Button, Top 5 Writing Style Analysis Violations by Recipient Widget, Configuring Mobile Device Enrollment Settings, Configuring Azure Active Directory Integration, Configuring Active Directory Server Integration, Common Active Directory Synchronization Tool System Requirements, Updating Common Active Directory Synchronization Tool, Importing Active Directory Structure Manually, Specifying Active Directory Export Settings, Participating in Smart Protection Network, Worry-Free Business Security Migration System Requirements, Migrated Policy Setting Mapping for OfficeScan, Mapping: Predictive Machine Learning Settings, Restoring an Encrypted File Using the Graphical Interface, Restoring an Encrypted File Using the Command Line Interface, Encrypting or Decrypting Files in Other Locations, Using Custom Criteria for Threat Investigation, Using OpenIOC Files for Threat Investigation, Incorrect Number of Endpoints on the Web Console, Security Agent Does Not Appear on the Web Console After Installation, Issues During Migration from Other Antivirus Software. The Web as I said earlier is a legacy machine. Also if this didn't answer your question, I can tell you in no uncertain terms that the solution will NOT involve shenanigans with `inputlookup` or `join`. The web started with this portionand works well all by itself, even if it isnt quite slick and sexy. That rule is disabled by default in a Balanced Security and Connectivity IPS ruleset. URL: Most have more side effects than this way does though, or is more fiddly and finicky or is less scalable. Most legitimate web requests from the Internet contain a user agent string. We can continue the discussion live. Description. So don't fall for the bad answers out there trying to get you to use those. user_agent="Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.2; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/60.0.3112.90 Safari/537.36" --> no alert, user_agent="Mozilla/5.0 (compatible; Nmap Scripting Engine; https://nmap.org/book/nse.html)" --> ALERT. I have several questions on registering Worry-Free Services. The specification here is acknowledging another part of the daily business reality. Thanks for all your help and thanks for the article links I have enjoyed reading them. If I am ever in doubt, I use that method to prove (usually to a customer) why Firepower (or more accurately the Talos security intelligence researchers who develop the rules) considers the rule as a true positive. Auto-suggest helps you quickly narrow down your search results by suggesting possible matches as you type. Which Agent installation method is best for my network environment? To ascertain what might be causing it on the endpoint can be a bit more difficult. Works fine on 98% of browsers & devices, yet might fail on new players, aka FirefoxOS. @Ronan All of these major brands fine-tune the user experience based on it, but do it well enough that most people dont even notice.. We both agree about the sensible defaults. I have several questions on registering Worry-Free Services. A user account was modified to password never expires; A user added a Windows firewall rule; A user authenticated with weak NTLM to multiple hosts; A user changed the Windows system time; A user cleared their browser's history; A user connected a USB storage device for the first time; A user connected a new USB storage device to a host What are the risks of enabling Ransomware Protection? I dont give up easy :). You don't have two columns in your CSV file, so you can either add one, or you can just OUTPUT the original field as "found". what i shoud do with that notification? Find specific objects in the list. Vulnerable SDK components lead to supply chain risks in IDAPython script to decode NightHawk strings. Much of this is noise, but more targeted attacks on websites using tools like Burp or SQLmap can sometimes be discovered by spotting uncommon user agents. Re: How to search suspicious user-agent in web req Five Subtly Different Ways of Adding Manual Instrumentation in Java, New Splunk APM Enhancements Help Troubleshoot Your MySQL and NoSQL Databases Faster. Initial portion of the host page for the first IP address Figure 2. Much of this is noise, but more targeted attacks on websites using tools like Burp or SQLmap can sometimes be discovered by spotting uncommon user agents. How to search suspicious user-agent in web request logs? Virtual Analyzer Suspicious Object List. Assuming we have no problems with lookups with special characters in them (I *think* that forward slashes won't bother anything? What follows is an account of our teams findings after we were brought in to assist in the investigation. We were able to isolate the internal sources of this unusual communication to a specific department (accounting) and group of staffers from within that department. Do note that there are definitely other ways to do this, too. How realistically is that we could find a user that would use our system on such outdated device? Which creates plenty of secondary issues. Im also a single developer making my own page. They identified what appeared to be Chinese and Korean alphabet characters in the HTTP user agent fields within protocol transactions on the accounting departments How the FBI Stumbled in the War on Cybercrime. User agent refers to any software that establishes an interaction between end-user and web content. Detecting these types of malware is often as easy as analyzing the rarest user-agent strings on your network. If you want to choose the best user agents for web scraping, check Get an analysis of your or any other user agent string. Since number of computers were limited first year students had only some UNIX terminals at their disposal. index=X | lookup bad_user_agent user_agent OUTPUT user_agent AS found | search found=*. Sending Suspicious Content to Trend Micro. I have created a custom action to send client strings directly to the site from within Investigator. Now the tendency is to design for WebKit. Do note that there are definitely other ways to do this, too. But let get the record straight. Gives talks & blogs about HTML5, JavaScript & the Open Web. So give it a try and let us know what you think. To request more information about how Stamus Security Platform can help your organization or to schedule a live demonstration, please click on the link below to contact us. And this method can often be quicker, less network intensive, and even more accurate than an active vulnerability and compliance scanner. The HTTP Protocol as defined in 1991 didnt have this field, but the next version defined in 1992 added User-Agent in the HTTP requests headers. If you find that, say, forward slashes cause problems, you can remove them with rex from your data before doing the lookup, and in that case just remove them from the lookup too before resaving the csv file. You don't have two columns in your CSV file, so you can either add one, or you can just OUTPUT the original field as "found". If yes dont forget to ping me. Security, Identity, & Compliance Serverless Front-End Web & Mobile Networking & Content Delivery. Updating databases and algorithms for identifying correctly is a very high maintenance task which is doomed to fail at a point in the future. I tested by adding a word "java" into my bad_user_agent list. New solutions are being developed for helping people to adjust the user experience depending on the capabilities of the products, not its name. > This is the case only with poor implementations that dont have sensible defaults. First how low do you go when in supporting low-end devices? Hehe. Each time it fails because a person had a different device, with different capabilities or the wrong brand. Legacy Defender-IoT-micro-agent: Suspicious compilation detected. Second part of the host page for the first IP address Here, we can see that specific clients from the accounting department are using Chinese and Koreanalphabet characters in the HTTP user communications. Please feel free to star the repository to keep in Splunk Observability has two new enhancements to make it quicker and easier to troubleshoot slow or frequently 2005-2022 Splunk Inc. All rights reserved. > Responsive design helps to create Web sites that are adjusting for different screen sizes. Domain: Philosophy of Web dev. Yes. Hopefully this gives you a taste of how the Stamus Security Platform can help security teams know more, respond sooner, and mitigate the risk to their organizations. Machine learning job: packetbeat_rare_user_agent, Searches indices from: now-45m (Date Math format, see also Additional look-back time), Last modified (Elastic Stack release): 8.5.0, Web activity that is uncommon, like security scans, may trigger this alert and may need to be excluded. This will change. And, I hope you have at least one other field in that lookup? Instead, we mostly saw a number of expected regular engagements from business partners operating in expected locations. These images typically include a hardened operating system, a default browser, a version of Java, the company's preferred Office workflow application suite, and other helper applications such as flash, PDF reader, and a standardized AV suite. I am implementing it in my products with a mixed degree of success. When possible, RSA Firstwatch members will use this space to share information about some of our findings. How to search suspicious user-agent in web request logs? Uncommon user agents coming from remote sources to local destinations are often the result of scanners, bots, and web scrapers, which are part of common Internet background traffic. What I was mentioning in my previous comment. Learn. It will not be perfect, but its more about having a practice which upgrades itself to a more advanced environment than trying to downgrade the experience. Anyway :). It should be included. Except where otherwise noted, content on this site is licensed Again I apologize if I am a bit negative, or boring, but I find this topic very important. Also if this didn't answer your question, I can tell you in no uncertain terms that the solution will NOT involve shenanigans with `inputlookup` or `join`. Remember that there are huge benefits to create a system which is resilient to many situations. Figure 1: If you are using obsolete or rare user agents, there is a big chance that a web server identifies a web scraping process as suspicious and you may be blocked. Most legitimate web requests from the Internet contain a user agent string. Your packet view that you provided clearly shows the user string so it's definitely not a false positive. agent masquerades as a different user agent, recipients can assume How can I recover a lost or forgotten password? Click Add to specify a file, IP address, URL, or domain type of * Web testing Assuming we have no problems with lookups with special characters in them (I *think* that forward slashes won't bother anything? On the getting rusty & breakage point, yes, user agent detection requires updates and maintenance (typically outsourced to a service) but so too do countless other aspects of their web publishing infrastructure. Google Chrome, w/ all $$$ spent in marketing did reach 30% in 4 years! URL. names, product names, or trademarks belong to their respective owners. nmap. That would deserve an article about the way people are using feature detections and responsive designs. We are lucky because in the case of the NBA, we have very nice responsive people on their team helping us to fix the issue and do the appropriate sniffing. field values increase request latency and the risk of a user being Worry-Free Business Security Services 6.7 Server Help, Privacy and Personal Data Collection Disclosure, Overview of Trend Micro It seems to be an easy solution at first but it creates an environment easy to by-pass in spoofing the user agent. User-Agent based attacks are a low-key risk that shouldn't be overlooked. Old, unpatched vulnerabilities allow hackers to take over systems using the User-Agent string -- an elementary part of virtually every HTTP request. But with today's malware and adware, many of these endpoint alterations to your Gold Release comes accidentally via Java exploits, Adware phishing or trojanized flash games. 03-29-2020 Sorting by most frequent occurrence probably wouldnt yield anything interesting other than a list of normal browsers in use on the network. UA sniffing is not a future fail strategy, it sadly is a necessary evil. * Mozilla/5.0 No its not :) Theres a silent evidence thing going on hereone notices the failures but not the successes. Im not sure, I understand this one. How do I copy the Identifier information? Right? It was a typical Friday afternoon or at least thats what the Stamus Networks incident support team was thinking. in 1997, I was working in a Web agency for two years already. Welcome to Splunk Education! to separate multiple entries. Some devices will not have JavaScript, will not have the right token. Bigger companies may have the developers to throw at detecting multiple devices and giving them individual treatment, but I certainly dont. However as we kept digging, our analyst discovered a series of transactions involving very unusual HTTP user agents. It makes extra bandwidth consumption and feature detection tools like Modernizer are not making any sense for well know devices. Figure 3. How can I perform a mass deployment to Mac? All other brand https://blogs.msdn.com/b/ie/archive/2010/03/23/introducing-ie9-s-user-agent-string.aspx?Redirected=true, http://www.nczonline.net/blog/2010/01/12/history-of-the-user-agent-string/, https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=843154, http://stephanierieger.com/a-plea-for-progressive-enhancement/, Creative Commons Attribution Share-Alike License v3.0, Use responsive design for your new mobile sites (media queries), If you are using a specific feature, use feature detections to enhance, not block. Once that Gold Release is pushed out to the endpoints, Enterprise managers typically expend a lot of audit hours and time to ensure that the endpoints aren't changed too badly by the users or by unauthorized software installations. You can see just how different an experience these brands serve up to different devices here: http://prism.mobiforge.com. I am in completely different waters doing stuff in may spare time, trying to learn how to make my apps as good as possible on wide range of devices, most much weaker that my six core 8GB desktop or Nexus 4 mobile, while trying to keep the work load low so I manage to complete my apps in a reasonable time. Taking Google as an example, their homepage /looks/ the same on all devices but in fact varies massively depending on what youre using. * like Gecko No, really thats not the case. Plus, the maintenance savings in the end are ridiculous compared to user agent string detection. Like said previously, dont bash the technology just cause some are misusing it (yes Google experiment Im looking at you!!). And, I hope you have at least one other field in that lookup? A global provider of high-performance network-based threat detection and response systems, Stamus Networks helps enterprise security teams know more, respond sooner and mitigate their risk with insights gathered from cloud and on-premise network activity. Requests from or any later version. After years of desktop web development at my company where my requests always were make it work in IE7 and above on screen size 1024X768 and above I am trying to develop some open source web apps that might end up on Firefox OS. Its not about the working cases but about the many times it fails. Im agree its long, complicated, on the long run, and need to be updated every month at least, but editing content for thousand devices cant be an easy task: deal with it! Auto-suggest helps you quickly narrow down your search results by suggesting possible matches as you type. Unfortunately, there are so many old user agents that break these rules that I fear User Agent Strings will always be a useless aspect of practical HTTP. I did a lookup csv file that included suspicious user-agents characters like below. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. I already extracted user_agent field from the log. Thats true. I need alert if user_agent field in web request log Worry-Free Business Security Services, Worry-Free Business Security Services >> Responsive design helps to create Web sites that are adjusting for different screen sizes. Description. yes testing for many devices maintaining algorithms and logic is very resource intensive and it is breaking stuff at large. Its syntax was defined as the software product name, with an optional slash and version designator. If you are getting an Intrusion Event, you can drill down in FMC under Analysis > Intrusions > Events and go into the Packets workflow. User-Defined Suspicious Object List Tasks; Task. It has deep roots into the way you are creating responsive design for your Web site. do you think blocking that ip address would solve the problem? Uncommon user agents in So don't fall for the bad answers out there trying to get you to use those. Known bad no because most of the time when you have a bad user-bad it is because of spelling,spacing,etc mistakes. Add objects. [Suggestions] Malware Detection Analysis Using Machine Russian Cybercrime Group steals 50 million passwords from Press J to jump to the feed. Creative Commons Attribution Share-Alike License v3.0 Execution: High: Suspicious double extension file executed: Analysis of host data indicates an execution Can other programs be allowed to update Intuit files? Start with solid, well formed HTML. So instead you take your list of user-strings in your environment and filter out those that are good, the rest are bad. Does Worry-Free Services support 64-bit platforms? Auto-suggest helps you quickly narrow down your search results by suggesting possible matches as you type. Google Chrome, w/ all $$$ spent in marketing did reach 30% in 4 years! When you encounter a suspicious user agent string, you can usually identify some information about it by pasting it into, a favorite site of mine when performing this hunt. Once youve found something interesting, start by performing a simple Google search on the user agent string. Aaron leads a 24/7 Security Operation Centre in the Middle East. I already extracted user_agent field from the log. nmap. I have a file right now on my drive with 386844 unique User Agent strings. If the source is unexpected, the user unauthorized, or the request unusual, these may indicate suspicious or malicious activity. However, uncommon user agents from local sources can also be due to malware or scanning activity. Assuming we have no problems with lookups with special characters in them (I *think* that forward slashes won't bother anything? * Bots User-Agent strings have many forms, and typically look similar to one of the following examples: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Ronan, Karl first of thanks for insightful comments. How to search suspicious user-agent in web request logs? I tested by adding a word "java" into my bad_user_agent list. Table 1. For example, how can I make rule to block all requests with user-agent as. Understand what information is contained in a user agent string. This is a very valid point and a more general question about the type of Web we are building. What is happening with user agent detection and tailored response from the server is that very often they make an assumption for the user. The Web is a legacy code and content machine. Its not a rhetorical question. You can also specify the scan action that the Security Agent performs after The issues described in the article are not about giving a good experience to well known devices but about blocking the unknown devices. I have written the article and Im an employee of Mozilla since last July, but that doesnt make this article be Mozilla in any fashion, not more than one of the voices of the community. Can other programs be allowed to update Intuit files? All of these major brands fine-tune the user experience based on it, but do it well enough that most people dont even notice. Use the drop-down list or search field to filter objects. Agree, this is where this mechanism needs constant work and updates. The stones on the path are plenty, choose the way of the simplicity. > RFC 1945 (HTTP 1.0, May 1996) and RFC 2616 (HTTP 1.1, June 1999) says the same thing. Please feel free to star the repository to keep in Splunk Observability has two new enhancements to make it quicker and easier to troubleshoot slow or frequently 2005-2022 Splunk Inc. All rights reserved. > User-Agent sniffing is a future fail strategy. You don't have two columns in your CSV file, so you can either add one, or you can just OUTPUT the original field as "found". Fully by faking totally the user agent, partially by things like: Mozilla/5.0 (iPad; CPU OS 6_0_2 like Mac OS X) AppleWebKit/536.26 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/6.0 Mobile/10A550 Safari/8536.25. A Web site should be working without JS or anything and still be readable on a low-end device. that the user intentionally desires to see responses tailored for What should I do if I am unable to connect to the server while installing the Security Agent? Technical Evangelist & Editor of Mozilla Hacks. Device : firepowerTimestamp : 2020-03-30 10:18:53Protocol : tcpAlert Message : MALWARE-CNC User-Agent known malicious user-agent string AutoIt (1:18347:10)Session : x.x.x.x:49644 -> 209.95.55.249:80[*] 0 more events originated from this Source IP. Many Git commands accept both tag and branch names, so creating this branch may cause unexpected behavior. It is a UX and a business decision. Here's a couple of vulnerabilities specific to when a system parses the User-Agent string from a web browser or any other HTTP request. When a web browser requests a page from a web server, it sends out a string containing information on the platform, operating system and software installed on the requesting computer. A machine learning job detected a rare and unusual user agent indicating web browsing activity by an unusual process other than a web browser. We are in the process of dealing with representatives of the Web site. Since the Firepower is identifying it as an intrusion event it should already be blocking the destination IP address. I have seen that in my last 20 years of doing the Web ;), another good article when Responsive design go rogue and why it is important to design with low capabilities in mind. for each individual HTTP request to a server. Some companies will be using the User-Agent string as an identifier for bypassing a pay-wall or offering specific content for a group of users during a marketing campaign. Second responsive design is all fine and dandy dont get me wrong I like it a lot. With the help of the Stamus Security Platform, one of our European financial services customers made an interesting discovery of suspicious activity on their network that resulted in a substantial incident investigation and response. subproducts by third parties. If you need help understanding what all of the pieces of a User-Agent string represent, there are online resources that decode them for you. They lie about what they really are and they are used for branding and advertising the devices they run on. Then your search is a little simpler. Let's assume for a second you have a second field in there, you can use it like so: That would snag all your web logs, then run a lookup against them using your lookup, using the user_agent as the key, and would output the contents of that other field you had into a new field named "found". That is why utilizing fault tolerance in intelligent ways is great. identified against their wishes (fingerprinting). Basically, it is about history, the fabric of time over content. We recommend you to limit your detection to the simplest possible string by matching the substring mobi in lowercase. And I didnt think you were negative in your comments. The User-Agent request header contains a characteristic string that allows the network protocol peers to identify the application type, OS, software vendor or software version of the requesting software User Agent. I would typically use something like SysInternals tcpview utility in Windows to determine what process (if it's not the browser) is making the connections to the address shown in the event. Are there any lists of known bad user agents? Because IP address information is crucial for almost all investigations, configuring known IP addresses helps our machine learning algorithms identify known locations and consider them as part of the machine learning models. To try to finish my comment on a positive note. under the alert http $HOME_NET any -> $EXTERNAL_NET any (msg:"ET POLICY Suspicious User Agent (AskInstallChecker? Design for the Web not for software or devices. More articles by Robert Nyman [Editor emeritus]. The Host page displays all the services, user agents, JA3 fingerprints, usernames, hostnames associated with a given asset, based on protocol transactions observed by Stamus Security Platform. In this situation, the customer is a subsidiary of a large European banking and insurance conglomerate (also a customer) with a mix of on-premise, branch office, public and private cloud assets. with them, as this circumvents the purpose of the field. If you've already registered, sign in. Why still serving CSS2, png, or nojs fallback to an iPad?! For example, adding the IP address range of your VPN wil How can I perform a mass deployment to Mac? As I said previously, Design for the less advanced and improve with feature detection instead of user agent. Each time you detect a product or a feature, it is important to thoroughly understand why you are trying to detect this feature. I usually prefer the other way around. Every mature Enterprise strives to create a standardized image for their endpoint workstations, and they often refer to this image as their "Gold Release." The bank confirmed they do not do business in China or Koreanor do they have any knowncustomers or partners in Asia, so we continued the investigation. Responsive design helps to create Web sites that are adjusting for different screen sizes. You see the rabbit hole we are going into. There are different scenarios where users fake the user agent string of the client. All other brand ;). A low end device in a rural area of Africa might not be the same of a what is called a low-end device on the 101 motorway in the silicon valley. Who could tell me how to be sure whether this IPS event (MALWARE-CNC User-Agent known malicious user-agent string AutoIt ) is false positive. I have highlighted the AWI v3 user-agent string. indefinitely. We Stamus Networks believes in a world where defenders are heroes, and a future where those they protect remain safe. I think were mostly agreed on the important stuffsites should default to delivering a low-end experience, and use whatever technique they wish to enrich this experience if the client supports it. user_agent="Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 6.2; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/60.0.3112.90 Safari/537.36" --> no alert, user_agent="Mozilla/5.0 (compatible; Nmap Scripting Engine; https://nmap.org/book/nse.html)" --> ALERT. If not, escalate the alert to the information security team. Anyways, just my two cents. that identified user agent, even if they might not work as well for python. Lastly, just search for where, after all that, the "found" field is there and set to something. Sign up for the Mozilla Developer Newsletter: If you havent previously confirmed a subscription to a Mozilla-related newsletter you may have to do so. thanks so much. Unfortunately, because this is a sensitive issue and an ongoing investigation, we are not allowed to share further details at this pointEven if the story remains incomplete, we believe this example shows the power of the Stamus Security Platform to correlate network flow data and security events and uncover an ongoing attack that had previously gone unnoticed by other security monitoring tools. You could fall in the same traps as the ones existing with user agent detection algorithms. ;) Its usually a good training for your own projects. Splunk training programs are designed to enable you to get started quickly and You can find the code of this example on GitHub here. User agent detection (or sniffing) is the mechanism used for parsing the User-Agent string and inferring physical and applicative properties about the device and its browser. > How can a developer like me realistically determine what is the low-end experience users can reliably receive? I cannot answer your question but I went down this path a long while ago when I first entered Infosec. objects. Its not like its a bunch of static HTML sitting on server somewhere so it doesnt feel correct to say that user agent detection is a more significant weakness in the future operation of these systems than anything else is. By doing this we would not lose many users, if any, but would save developers from much, probably unnecessary, work. A user agent SHOULD NOT generate a User-Agent field containing They are abused in every possible way. This is the case only with poor implementations that dont have sensible defaults. r/cybersecurity Im Nick Percoco, Chief Security Officer at Kraken and founder of SpiderLabs at Trustwave and THOTCON - hacker conference in Chicago. Remember that whatever the number of tokens you put there, you will fail at a point in the future. >But on the real world, a new platform or browser is not coming out from nowhere and be > 10% of the market share in a couple days. MALWARE-CNC User-Agent known malicious user-agent string AutoIt, Customers Also Viewed These Support Documents. And of course, now that you know that string is malicious, a simple rule can be written to create an alert to notify you of its presence in the future. in any case, hopefully this answers your question. :) And nitpicking, hello-gurus displays nice on Firefox for Android, but fails on Firefox OS. You might decide to not care about certain devices and browsers, but then again, here it is a different philosophy which is not the Web I want. Or if you have another solution for my task, please feel free to tell me. bad_user_agent. What happens when an attempted Intuit update is blocked? in any case, hopefully this answers your question. * Web Compatibility hehe hear hear about the NBA. True, and that is very useful but responsive design doesnt help web sites that need to support a wide range of devices, going all the way down to low-end feature phones. If whatever endpoint protection is not already catching it, a deeper investigation may be required. I cant think of a single website that supports the full range of web clients (feature phone -> smartphone -> tablet -> desktop -> TV) that has managed to make progressive enhancement work. Or if you have another solution for my task, please feel free to tell me. It is often frustrating enough that end users install silly software that isn't needed- like Weatherbug, Yahoo Search Toolbars, Daily Coupon Alerting software- and even more frustrating when users install applications that violate corporate policy such as Online Backup suites, XDrive, Bittorrent, MIRC or other applications. the ENTER key What should I do when Behavior Monitoring and Ransomware Protection are not working? It is a different site. Results of searching for specific strings used in HTTP user agents.Figure 7. For more information, see Adding Objects to the User-Defined Suspicious Object List. Figure 8. needlessly fine-grained detail and SHOULD limit the addition of By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. URL: Specify the How do I copy the Identifier information? the actual user agent being used. Robert is a strong believer in HTML5 and the Open Web and has been working since 1999 with Front End development for the web - in Sweden and in New York City. Specify the Type of object. Things only start to break when we (heavy handedly) introduce complex CSS and JS. Why asking an iPad or a Nexus4 if it supports svg, CSS gradients or which video codec it can play on every damn page load?! History of the user-agent string http://www.nczonline.net/blog/2010/01/12/history-of-the-user-agent-string/. 11:40 PM No, you don't need to check every time because Firepower has a VERY low false positive rate. Now error is gone but my query is not show any result. Splunk training programs are designed to enable you to get started quickly and You can find the code of this example on GitHub here. Use these resources to familiarize yourself with the community: We are changing the way you share Knowledge Articles - Click to read more! The sheer volume (100s of millions) of daily network log transactions creates a massive haystack in which to find the proverbial needle in the haystack. You don't have two columns in your CSV file, so you can either add one, or you can just OUTPUT the original field as "found". Use commas, semicolons, or Stop lying to me. :), Thats pretty funny to read this on a Mozilla website, since you guys werent really against UA sniffing when it was all about sniffing out IE6 10 years ago ;). Then your search is a little simpler. Do remember that your UA string is being used countless times per day to improve your experience by the likes of Google, Facebook, eBay, Amazon, Netflix etc. Because if found is already a field in the CSV, then we just output that. It is not only Mozilla products, every product and brand has to deal at a point with the fact to be excluded because they didnt have the right token to pass an ill-coded algorithm. I need alert if user_agent field in web request log contains any word in csv file. Uncommon user agents in traffic from local sources to remote destinations can be any number of things, including harmless programs like weather monitoring or stock-trading programs. Lastly, just search for where, after all that, the "found" field is there and set to something. I get this notification very often. What should I do when Behavior Monitoring and Ransomware Protection are not working? Most have more side effects than this way does though, or is more fiddly and finicky or is less scalable. Now if you look very carefully at these 3 sites, they do not offer the same content and the same information (not talking about the layout). I continue to enjoy wine despite having a bad bottle from time to time. A searchable database of user-agents as used by browsers, search-engines spiders and crawlers, web-directories, download managers, link checkers, proxy servers, web filtering tools, harvesters, spambots, badbots. Where can I find my registration information? To make it short, it is basically lightly brushed in the sentence You could fall in the same traps as the ones existing with user agent detection algorithms. Sometimes Responsive designs and/or feature detections are used to degrade the user experience for devices with lower capabilities. This is what is happening. I should use the method you taught me when i need to be sure whether the event is false positive or not, right? A tag already exists with the provided branch name. :) It seems to be an easy answer, it is not. See the series of translations in Figure 8 below. But how practical would this approach be? It then becomes very annoying when the site forbids me by automatic redirection to access one or the other site based on my environment. Click Add to specify a file, IP address, URL, or domain type of object. If the site is the not working now on newer devices because of scripting and/or screen sizes, it exactly shows how wrong we were. So nah you are not that old ;). Which Agent installation method is best for my network environment? We have to deal with reality unfortunately. Very often redirection based on user agent detection is not used to show the same content with the markup and the layout tailored for mobile devices. Otherwise, register and sign in. i get same notification every day. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. I think most people have different assumptions on what is the normal base depending on our own environment context. They currently do UA sniffing and that creates issues for Firefox OS because it was not in the list of user agents which were detected. Result is 0 even if user_agent field have a word "java". Right? Then, several months later, I added more bad user agents, compressed the list into single-line format, and released the Ultimate .Htaccess Blacklist 2. Fast forward to August 2013, the HTTP/1.1 specification is being revised and also defines User-Agent. Likewise, implementations are encouraged not to use the product File: Click Find answers to your questions by entering keywords or phrases in the Search bar above. Usual caveat of "Your Mileage May Vary" applies. How can I recover a lost or forgotten password? Introducing IE9s User-Agent string https://blogs.msdn.com/b/ie/archive/2010/03/23/introducing-ie9-s-user-agent-string.aspx?Redirected=true registered trademarks of Splunk Inc. in the United States and other countries. I just want to ask some very practical questions. file. A google search shows that this string is a known malicious string used to download additional trojan horses according to VirusTotal. Creating rules to normalize your user-agent strings will allow you to passively monitor your endpoints for out-of-date applications and unauthorized software. :) It will be fine plenty of time, and indeed it helps create services directed to one person. Currently, the user agent strings have become overly long. The low-end should be the norm (personal opinion). Find lists of user agent strings from browsers, crawlers, spiders, bots, validators and others.. This new list features a So I put in the extra effort at the start and bank on the fact that I can test a responsive design on my laptop, tablet, and phone and the gaps will be okay, too. Our analyst decided to initiate the hunt from scratch to see if we would come to the same conclusions as the banks analysts. User-Agent: is a string of characters sent by HTTP clients (browsers, bots, calendar applications, etc.) Could you define what is a low-end device? As a matter of facts, I often used for some sites the mobile domain name on my *laptop* because I want this type of content. There will be many road blocks on the way depending on the context, the business requirements, the social infrastructure of your own company. Use the list to add objects you consider suspicious but are not currently in the It is really not a naive question because there are still legacy browsers that dont support a lot of features user in modern web development. :) I dont think we will resolve this one. Please check your inbox or your spam filter for an email from us. names, product names, or trademarks belong to their respective owners. How can I verify that all ransomware-related settings are enabled? It doesnt solve WAP low-end devices, and its why the checklist is proposed as a Zen practice and not as rules. I have highlighted the AWI v3 user-agent string. All rights Reserved. Its why HTTP/1.1 bis is near completion (Last Call) and should be published very soon, it includes the prose I put in that post. The prose already invited people to use it for analytics and identify the products with implementation issues. Thats what i was talking about. I have the same question as your first one, but I have a different perspective on the second one. The issue is with the other part which is not in the most people ;) see for example http://mzl.la/164Mj9x Thats the issue which is at stake. Its here https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=843154. These are user agents that might have only been seen a couple of times or on a single host. So don't fall for the bad answers out there trying to get you to use those. If you don't have a second field in the CSV lookup yet, you can add a field to it and make it easy for yourself by calling it "found" and setting it to 1 everywhere in the CSV. I need alert if user_agent field in web request log contains any word in csv file. As you say, its not only long and complicated, it fails all the time. User-agent names are constantly invented, spoofed, or otherwise altered in order to operate beneath or above the virtual radar. Thus, a user-agent blacklist is a high-maintenance affair, requiring continuous cultivation in order to maintain relevancy and effectiveness. Performance is another important issue to consider. It refers to a mobile-first strategy backed w/ server-side profiling to generate optimized CSS & JS files. Review with the user that ran the command if this was legitimate activity that you expect to see on the device. IP address: Specify the IP address. All of these use cases express the *user intent*, not the server intent. So basically, desiging for the lowest possible and improving with mediaqueries for bigger sizes and/or more capabilities. * Bypassing firewalls. Go to POLICIES > User-Defined Suspicious Objects. What are the risks of enabling Ransomware Protection? New here? registered trademarks of Splunk Inc. in the United States and other countries. What is the maximum number of devices and groups that Worry-Free Services can support? How to search suspicious user-agent in web request Five Subtly Different Ways of Adding Manual Instrumentation in Java, New Splunk APM Enhancements Help Troubleshoot Your MySQL and NoSQL Databases Faster. Are you asking your friend their name and what they do for a living everytime they come by? We createD sites in the past by targeting specific capabilities, such as a screen size or specific JS. Because if found is already a field in the CSV, then we just output that. I tested by adding a word "java" into my bad_user_agent list. Correct me if Im wrong, but does the following not mean EXACTLY that tailoring responses to specific user agent strings is an intended use? but I suspect you are talking about the case where the design is not mobile first. All of these have costs in resources and branding. ==== Threat mapping, https://www.elastic.co/guide/en/security/current/prebuilt-ml-jobs.html, https://attack.mitre.org/techniques/T1071/. A user accessed an abnormal number of files on a remote shared folder; A user accessed an uncommon AppID; A user accessed multiple time-consuming websites; A user accessed The catastrophic UA detection we experience on a daily basis is often not visible for users who are deep into the technology, because they have a tendency to use the last shiny toys and software. Nitpicking, hello-gurus displays nice on Firefox OS, as this circumvents the purpose of the simplicity some UNIX at... Are creating responsive design is not already catching it, but I certainly.. By HTTP clients ( browsers, crawlers, spiders, bots, validators and others implementing. Will resolve this one the detections column to go to the User-Defined suspicious Object.... See on the network be the norm ( personal opinion ) a future strategy. Many situations ransomware-related settings are enabled by default in a web browser or other! Security Services find specific objects in the investigation it on the second one blacklist is a legacy code content... From Business partners operating in expected locations your question yet might fail on new players aka... Why utilizing fault tolerance in intelligent ways is great clients ( browsers, bots, calendar applications, mistakes... Of characters sent by HTTP clients ( browsers, bots, calendar applications, etc )... Bandwidth consumption and feature detection tools like Modernizer are not that old ; ) its usually a good for... That ran the command if this was legitimate activity that you expect to see on the suspicious user agent list. Updating databases and algorithms for identifying correctly is a legacy machine 24/7 Operation! Were limited first year students had only some UNIX terminals at their disposal not. Testing ) Bada or WebOS a very high maintenance task which is resilient to situations. Could tell me expected locations based attacks are a low-key risk that should n't overlooked... Used in HTTP user agents us know what you think blocking that IP address found | search found= * requiring. Home_Net any - > $ EXTERNAL_NET any ( msg: '' ET POLICY suspicious user agent string resolve one... Well for python up to different devices here: hello gurus website uses server-side profiling to optimized... Going on hereone notices the failures but not the case sites in the same thing a Balanced Security and IPS! Capability, we were easily able to identify all the offending systems it in products. Autoit ) is false positive rate your question network environment we will resolve this.... Is about history, the maintenance savings in the csv, then just..., JavaScript & the Open web these brands serve up to different devices here::. Causing it on the second one or search field to filter objects brought. Of user-strings in your comments be an easy answer, it is because of spelling,,. Logs the diversity in terms of physical characteristics will only increase information about some of teams... Screen sizes every time because Firepower has a very valid point and a more general about... To access one or the request unusual, these may indicate suspicious or malicious activity by. One or the other site based on it, a user-agent field containing they are used to the... Result is 0 even if they might not work as well for python even! Url, or exfiltration activity achieve if your web site suspicious user agent list be working without JS or anything and be. Can support are huge benefits to create a system parses the user-agent request-header field information. States and other countries fact varies massively depending on our own environment context you say, its only. Be allowed to update Intuit files due to persistence, command-and-control, is. Job detected a rare and unusual user agent originating the request unusual these... Mobile first me by automatic redirection to access one or the wrong brand user-bad it not! Complex CSS and JS in them ( I * think * that slashes... Elementary part of the field where the design is all fine and dandy get! Of this example on GitHub here fake the user experience for devices with lower capabilities Security Identity... Machine Russian Cybercrime Group steals 50 million passwords from Press J to jump to the User-Defined Object! A bit more difficult or search field to filter objects not simple one page demo site. Invited people to adjust the user string so it 's definitely not a future those... Nah you are talking about the type of web we are in end! Not simple one page demo on a positive note the browsing experience system parses the user-agent request-header field contains about. Settings are enabled: //blogs.msdn.com/b/ie/archive/2010/03/23/introducing-ie9-s-user-agent-string.aspx? Redirected=true registered trademarks of splunk Inc. in the investigation request-header field contains information some! By matching the substring mobi in lowercase these are user agents everytime they come by to... Had only some UNIX terminals at their disposal -- an elementary part of virtually every HTTP request or. An elementary part of virtually every HTTP request a legacy machine 2616 ( 1.1. For different screen sizes 03-29-2020 Sorting by most frequent occurrence probably wouldnt yield interesting. Same traps as the ones existing with user agent, recipients can how! The count in the United States and other countries complex CSS and JS come the! Do it well enough that most people have different assumptions on what is low-end... Are adjusting for different screen sizes run on Accept both tag and branch names, or is less scalable Middle! Maintaining algorithms and logic is very resource intensive and it is important to understand... Different devices here: HTTP: //prism.mobiforge.com and, I was working in a Balanced Security Connectivity., work breaking stuff at large uncommon user agents from local sources can also be due to persistence,,! Protect remain safe realistically determine what is happening with user agent detection.... No problems with lookups with special characters in them ( I * think * that forward wo! Valid point and a future fail strategy, it is important to thoroughly why. Spiderlabs at Trustwave and THOTCON - hacker conference in Chicago that this string is a very false... Displays nice on Firefox for Android, but would save developers from much, probably unnecessary, work string an... Causing it on the second one Security Services, Worry-Free Business Security find... And/Or more capabilities range of your VPN wil how can I perform a mass deployment to?. Sense for well know devices I dont think we will resolve this one web we are building clicking Accept you... Poor implementations that dont have sensible defaults results of searching for specific strings used in HTTP user agents.Figure.... And unauthorized software different an experience these brands serve up to different devices here::! Whether this IPS event ( MALWARE-CNC user-agent known malicious user-agent string -- suspicious user agent list elementary part of the client the! Where, after all that, the `` found '' field is there set! And its why the checklist is proposed as a Zen practice and as., product names, or otherwise altered in order to maintain relevancy and effectiveness testing Bada. This, too to access one or the wrong brand because Firepower has a very point. A tag already exists with the community: we are changing the way you trying. To different devices here: HTTP: //prism.mobiforge.com every possible way, hello-gurus nice! //Www.Elastic.Co/Guide/En/Security/Current/Prebuilt-Ml-Jobs.Html, https: //www.elastic.co/guide/en/security/current/prebuilt-ml-jobs.html, https: //www.elastic.co/guide/en/security/current/prebuilt-ml-jobs.html, https: //attack.mitre.org/techniques/T1071/ its weight tolerance intelligent! Improving with mediaqueries for bigger sizes and/or more capabilities source is unexpected, the user experience on. Tolerance in intelligent ways is great them individual treatment, but I suspect you are trying to get you use... Emeritus ] improve with feature detection tools like Modernizer are not that old ; ) its usually good... In this article me wrong I like it a lot make an assumption the! Is more fiddly and finicky or is less scalable, a user-agent field containing are! Low do you think blocking that IP address range of your VPN wil how can I recover a lost forgotten... User-Agents characters like below to search suspicious user-agent in web request logs the simplicity tokens of other in... These are user agents in so do n't fall for the bad answers out there trying to started. Is about history, the `` found '' field is there and set to something monitor your endpoints out-of-date... Services directed to one person expect to see if we would come to the browsing experience $ EXTERNAL_NET any msg. Had a different user agent detection and tailored response from the Internet contain a user agent detection and response! Silent evidence thing going on hereone notices the failures but not the.. Of other implementations in order to operate beneath or above the virtual radar something! Design helps to create a system which is doomed to fail at a point in future... Well know devices and a more general question about the working cases but about the way people are feature! Known malicious user-agent string -- an elementary part of the daily Business reality and groups that Services! By an unusual process other than a web agency for two years already check time! Lying to me to use those for identifying correctly is a legacy code and content.. Happens when an attempted Intuit update is blocked in supporting low-end devices I tested by adding word! That old ; ) its usually a good training for your own projects consumption and feature detection tools like are! Different devices here: hello gurus website uses server-side profiling to generate optimized CSS & JS files HTTP request we... We are changing the way of the daily Business reality characters in them ( I * *! In conversations initiate the hunt from scratch to see on the endpoint can be a bit difficult. Attacks are a low-key risk that should n't be overlooked learn the of! Customers also Viewed these support Documents to assist in the United States other.